Ekurhuleni, Gauteng – An abduction that began as a terrifying disappearance ended in relief after Mbalenhle “Miranda” Nkomo, a resident of Windmill Park, was found alive on Sunday afternoon. She had been missing since Friday night, when she was allegedly abducted on her way to a midnight prayer service in Newtown, Johannesburg.

The shocking incident unfolded over two days, with the woman being taken across provinces and later released after her captors realised she was not the person they were targeting. What started as a simple journey of faith turned into an ordeal that has since raised serious concerns about growing abduction trends in South Africa and the chilling reality of mistaken identity.

The story has raised eyebrows among some members of the public who say several aspects remain unclear — particularly why she was kept for two days, driven across provinces, and then suddenly released. Some believe more details are yet to emerge.

Also Read | ZamaNguni Gumede Found Dead in Durban Flat

Abduction Caught Public Attention After Disappearance

Nkomo’s failure to arrive at the church service sparked panic among her family and community. Efforts to contact her were unsuccessful, and her vehicle was also reported missing. Within hours, news of her disappearance spread across social media platforms, triggering widespread concern.

Family members confirmed that she was headed to a midnight gathering and had not shown any signs of distress before the incident. Her sudden silence led to fears of an abduction, especially given the growing number of kidnapping reports across the province.

While many expressed relief, others questioned the full truth of the account, pointing out gaps in the timeline and inconsistencies in how the abduction unfolded.

“We’re glad she’s back, but something about the story feels off,” one commenter wrote. “They drove to KZN and back just to say ‘sorry, wrong person’? Doesn’t add up.”

Also Read | Missing Mother and Daughter Found Decapitated, 2 Arrested

Driven Across Provinces During the Abduction

Speaking shortly after her return, Nkomo’s husband shared disturbing details of the abduction. According to her account, the kidnappers panicked when they failed to locate the car tracker. Believing they had been tricked or exposed, they took her from Gauteng to KwaZulu-Natal in an attempt to manage the situation.

“She told me they kept driving for hours. They were clearly agitated. They went all the way to KwaZulu-Natal on Saturday and drove back on Sunday,” he said.

The abduction did not involve demands for ransom or violence. Instead, the men reportedly interrogated her and then realised that she was not the intended target.

Abduction Due to Mistaken Identity, Says Victim

Once the kidnappers began questioning her, they reportedly admitted to making a mistake. They had been looking for someone driving a similar vehicle, possibly based on incomplete or incorrect information. After realising the error, they dropped her and the car off at a petrol station.

Though she had not eaten since Friday and was traumatised, Nkomo was unharmed.

“She said they were calm but confused. She hadn’t eaten since Friday, but she’s safe and that’s all that matters,” her husband added.

Police Investigate Strange Circumstances of Abduction

Police have launched a formal investigation into the abduction. The vehicle is being examined for fingerprints and other evidence, and no arrests have been made so far. Investigators are also trying to determine whether the men involved are linked to a larger network or were acting alone.

Authorities suspect this may not be an isolated incident. Similar cases of mistaken abduction have been reported in recent months, raising questions about the methods used by criminal groups and the reliability of the intelligence they rely on.

“This case points to the possibility that victims are being abducted not based on personal targeting, but due to superficial or mistaken identification,” said a local law enforcement source.

Community Outrage and Calls for Better Protection

The abduction of a woman on her way to a church service has left the Windmill Park community shaken. Many residents have expressed relief at her safe return, but also fear for their safety.

“It could’ve been any one of us. She was just going to pray. Now we all have to think twice before leaving the house at night,” said a neighbour who asked not to be named.

On social media, users questioned how long she was in transit and why the men didn’t release her sooner once they knew she was not the intended victim. Others praised her bravery and calmness under pressure.

Abduction Trends on the Rise Across South Africa

This incident adds to a growing list of abductions reported across South Africa, many of which involve vehicle hijackings, ransom demands, or mistaken identity. The randomness of this case has highlighted the vulnerability of ordinary people who may be targeted due to car models, routine behaviours, or simply being in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Criminologists have warned that some syndicates are operating with poor or rushed information, increasing the risk of mistaken abductions. Victims like Nkomo are caught in the crossfire of criminal operations that prioritise speed over certainty.

“We need intelligence-driven policing, not reactive investigations,” said a Gauteng community safety advocate. “These abduction syndicates are acting on assumptions. That’s what makes them dangerous.”

Also Read | KZN Woman Murdered Abroad After System Ignored Her Warnings

Abduction Investigation Ongoing as Family Recovers

As Nkomo recovers from her traumatic experience, her family is calling for justice and better protection for vulnerable people, especially women travelling alone.

The abduction, while ultimately resolved without physical harm, has left emotional scars and lingering questions. How did the kidnappers track the wrong vehicle? How close did they come to harming her before they realised their error? And how many more cases like this remain unreported or unresolved?

At this stage, police have not released further information confirming or disputing the woman’s version of events. The investigation remains open.

Anyone with information related to the abduction is urged to contact the police immediately.